Incorporating Biodiversity in Pension Fund Investment Strategies
The planet’s biodiversity is being seriously depleted, threatening the viability of human existence. Since 1970, the Earth’s wildlife populations have fallen by almost 70% – a result of deforestation, excessive human consumption, and industrial scale pollution. Mother Nature’s cupboard cannot be raided forever without serious consequences.
While this is clearly of urgent concern to everyone, the Masterclass will focus specifically on the responsibilities and actions that pension trustees and investors can reasonably undertake to combat biodiversity loss and manage the attendant risks. Expect a candid and highly interactive debate, with delegates encouraged to engage proactively throughout.
Chair
Mark Thompson
Chair of the Trustee Board
M&G Pension Scheme
Keynote Speaker
Dr. Beccy Wilebore
Chief Science Officer
Natcap Research
Agenda
Devil's Advocates
Rachel Brougham, Trustee Executive, BESTrustees
Denise Le Gal, Chair, Brunel Pension Partnership
Mark Scantlebury, Co-Founder, Quietroom
A panel of Devil’s Advocates will be on duty for the course of the afternoon.
They will be available to pose challenging questions to any of the conference speakers when invited to do so by the Moderator of each session. They will provide an end of day summary of the main learning and action points from the conference.
13.10 – 13.30
Meet & Greet
13.30 – 13.45
Welcome & Introduction
Masterclass Chair:
Mark Thompson
Chair of the Trustee Board
M&G Pension Scheme
Programme Director:
Stephen Glover
Director
SG Pensions Enterprise
13.45 – 14.15
Keynote Address: Biodiversity – The Global Challenge
Dr. Beccy Wilebore
Chief Science Officer
Natcap Research
Our speaker, a leading scientist in the field, will define the nature of biodiversity, how it differs from natural capital and the scale of the challenge globally. She will discuss why measuring and managing biodiversity is inherently complex, and present key data on the proportion of world GDP dependent on nature and the potential impact of biodiversity loss on the global economy.
The connection with climate change will be illustrated and she will give a summary of the main initiatives to contain biodiversity loss, their likely outcomes and the role of the financial sector in the process.
14.15 – 15.00
Panel Discussion: The Legal & Fiduciary Case for Managing Biodiversity Risk
Moderator:
Carolyn Saunders
Pensions Partner
Pinsent Masons
Michael Bushnell
Head of Sustainability
Cardano Advisory
Carlos Martin Tornero
Senior ESG Specialist
Financial Conduct Authority
Nick Spencer
Sustainable Investment Strategist
Gordian Advice
Ambrogio Zanzi
Methodology Manager
Morningstar Sustainalytics
The panel will discuss what pensions trustees will be legally bound and required to do to manage biodiversity risk with reference to the UN Biodiversity Accord, developing management frameworks like TNFD, and whether reporting will become mandatory.
Speakers will explore the practicalities of biodiversity targets, whether these can be effectively measured and enforced, the level of clarity of fiduciary duties in relation to biodiversity risk, and how key players are interpreting and applying the rules. Major challenges will be confronted – notable among them are regulatory and compliance costs and the anti-ESG backlash in the US.
15.00 – 15.20
Coffee at Home & Online Networking
15.20 – 16.05
Panel Discussion: The Investment Case for Biodiversity
Moderator:
Jamie Broderick
Deputy Chair
Impact Investing Institute
Marian D’Auria
Chair of the Pensions Committee
Universities Superannuation Scheme
Rob Gardner
Co-CEO & Co-Founder
Rebalance Earth
Arne Klug
Director of Biodiversity Research
MSCI
Jon Wallace
Investment Manager,
Environmental Solutions
Jupiter Asset Management
The panel will focus on the investment opportunities that an increased focus on biodiversity factors will generate. Speakers will debate how these opportunities will manifest themselves, how to take advantage of them, and the changes to governance, skills procurement and asset allocation that will be required.
Key elements will be avoiding biodiversity losses while identifying – and monetising – biodiversity gains, and a consideration of the special return and risk characteristics of nature-based funds.
16.05 – 16.25
Presentation: Carbon & Biodiversity – Markets & Investment Opportunities
Charles Bedford
Chief Impact Officer
Carbon Growth Partners
David Ryan
Head of Distribution
Carbon Growth Partners
The global economy is increasingly adopting market-based approaches to address and rectify the economic externalities it has caused. However, it is challenging to find investments that deeply impact climate and biodiversity, particularly in developing countries, where such projects are often situated. Investors may now seek investments that go beyond mere ESG labels and negative screening criteria.
In this context, both the compliance and voluntary carbon markets, as well as the emerging biodiversity market, offer opportunities for investors interested in tangible outcomes related to carbon emissions, nature conservation, and human development, alongside achievable attractive risk-adjusted returns. These markets provide avenues for investments that can deliver environmental preservation, and socioeconomic progress.
16.25 – 17.05
Panel Discussion: Action Points for Trustees
Moderator:
Mark Thompson
Chair of the Trustee Board
M&G Pension Scheme
Emma Hunt
Head of Responsible Investment
HSBC Bank Pension Trust
Eugenie Matthieu
Earth Lead
Aviva Investors
Diandra Soobiah
Head of Responsible Investment
NEST
The panel will discuss what pensions trustees need to do to take account of biodiversity factors. Speakers will debate the practicalities of how to get biodiversity onto the trustee agenda, how advisers and managers can help, identifying sources of data and analysis to enable optimal decision making, selecting the best advisers, managing fees and costs, and determining what optimal outcomes should look like.
17.05 – 17.20
Devil's Advocates' Summary
Rachel Brougham
Trustee Executive
BESTrustees
Denise Le Gal
Chair
Brunel Pension Partnership
Mark Scantlebury
Co–Founder
Quietroom
The Devil’s Advocates will offer their summary and main takeaways from the afternoon’s proceedings.
17.20 – 17.30
Final Thoughts & Closing Remarks
Speakers
Charles Bedford
Chief Impact Officer
Carbon Growth Partners
Jamie Broderick
Deputy Chair
Impact Investing Institute
Rachel Brougham
Trustee Executive
BESTrustees
Michael Bushnell
Head of Sustainability
Cardano Advisory
Marian D'Auria
Independent NED
USS
Rob Gardner
Co-CEO & Co-Founder
Rebalance Earth
Arne Klug
Director of Biodiversity Research
MSCI
Emma Hunt
Head of Responsible Investment
HSBC Bank Pension Trust
Denise Le Gal
Chair
Brunel Pensions Partnership
Carlos Martín Tornero
Senior ESG Specialist
Financial Conduct Authority
Eugenie Matthieu
Earth Lead
Aviva Investors
David Ryan
Head of Distribution & Business Development
Carbon Growth Partners
Carolyn Saunders
Pensions Partner
Pinsent Masons
Mark Scantlebury
Co–Founder
Quietroom
Diandra Soobiah
Head of Responsible Investment
NEST
Nick Spencer
Sustainable Investment Strategist
Gordian Advice
Jon Wallace
Investment Manager,
Environmental Solutions
Jupiter Asset Management
Ambrogio Zanzi
Methodology Manager
Morningstar Sustainalytics