Sponsored By
Finding the Critical Path to Success
A climate change strategy for pension funds presents two overriding challenges: reaching a consensus definition of what would constitute success; and agreeing on a plan to get there. At the state level, genuine and widespread political will is going to be necessary to produce material results, while trustees will play the key role for asset owners in insisting on essential reforms. There is, however, much confusion over objectives and targets, many competing approaches even among climate change believers, and a large number of dissenting voices that remain powerful. As a result, avoidance strategies, not least inertia, are far too easy to come by and will constitute the line of least resistance without resolute and proactive leadership from key players.
In a highly interactive setting, delegates to the Masterclass will compare notes with some of the leading thinkers and practitioners in the battle against climate change. They will seek to clearly define the fault lines and responsibilities for pension funds, make sense of the new resources, innovations and instruments that are available in this key endeavour, and set a firmer course for the future.
Chair
Julius Pursaill
Independent Member
Royal London
Agenda
13.30 – 13.50
Meet & Greet
13.50 – 14.00
Welcome & Introduction
Chair:
Julius Pursaill
Independent Member
Board Investment Committee
Royal London
Programme Director:
Stephen Glover
Director
SG Pensions Enterprise
14.00 – 14.25
Keynote Presentation & Q&A:The Realistic Ambitions of a Net Zero Strategy
Tom Tayler
Senior Manager
Aviva Investors
The Masterclass is expressly scheduled a fortnight after the close of the COP26 conference in Glasgow. Our speaker will examine what was agreed at COP26, whether it represents genuine progress, and its implications for pension funds, especially as regards the continued relevance of Paris alignment as the main decision-making framework. They will set the overall challenge on what needs to be done, and the practicalities on what really can be done, by asset owners in particular, to combat the climate crisis.
14.25 – 15.05
Panel Discussion: In Defence of Net Zero
Moderator:
Julius Pursaill
Independent Member
Board Investment Committee
Royal London
Chandra Gopinathan
Senior Investment Manager
Railpen
Caroline Hopper
Senior Writer
Quietroom
Jeff Houston
Head of Pensions
Local Government Association
Carol Young
Trustee
Natwest DC Plan
There remain key differences of opinion as to whether net zero is the right target, what is meant by it, and whether pensions practitioners understand the same thing when they adopt a net zero strategy.
Our speakers will seek to clarify the definition, justify why net zero is the right goal and crucially, debate how ambitious that goal should be. They will equally consider what pension schemes should be doing and equally, should not be doing, in pursuit of these objectives. Delegates may expect to gain a far greater appreciation of the main ingredients of a workable net zero strategy as well as its realistic limitations.
15.05 – 15.20
Presentation:The Inconvenient Truths of Reaching Net Zero
James Wilde
Chief Sustainability Officer
Phoenix Group
With action needed now, the plain fact is that net zero commitments for 2040 or 2050 on their own will not really make a difference. Of far greater importance are short-term targets.
Our speaker will explore what nearer term commitments and related strategies -by 2025 and 2030 -are realistic, and argue that an implementation plan for achieving these is key. He will also address the critical issue that many asset owners can only act via third party asset managers, and discuss the practical steps that both pension funds and their advisers need to take in the short term to avoid inaction as a result.
15.20 – 15.40
Coffee at Home & Online Networking
15.40 – 16.10
Joint Presentations: The Latest Innovations for Decarbonising Pension Portfolios
Phil Beattie
Head of Sales
SparkChange
Ted Christie-Miller
Head of Carbon Removals
BeZero Carbon
Pensions schemes cannot reach a net zero emissions portfolio in one step, not least because the companies in which they invest need to accomplish their own transitions. In the meantime, there are carbon offsets, emission permits, carbon credits, and markets and exchanges that have been established to broker the reduction of emissions among multiple financial market players on a global basis. In this session, delegates will have the opportunity to learn about new tradable liquid financial assets that offer both a direct hedge against the price of carbon and have positive real world climate impact.
16.15 – 16.55
Expert Discussion Groups
Group 1: Advances in Stewardship Approaches
Facilitator:
Karen Shackleton
Founder & Chair
Pensions for Purpose
Lead Discussants:
Mike Clark
Founder Director
Ario Advisory
Mel Jarman
Policy Maker
Department for Work & Pensions
Jennifer Law
Head of Stewardship
Newton Investment Management
Georgia Stewart
Co-Founder & CEO
Tumelo
Themes:
- What does ‘good’ stewardship look like within a net zero strategy?
- The new skills that trustees and fiduciaries will need
- Is best practice stewardship affordable?
- Are stewardship and engagement strategies different between DB and DC asset owners?
- Is engagement a sine qua non compared with divestment?
- Coordinating objectives more closely with managers
Group 2: Net Zero Alignment Metrics
Facilitator:
Marian Elliott
Global Head of Pensions
GFG Alliance
Lead Discussants:
Bruno Bamberger
Solutions Strategist
AXA Investment Managers
David Farrar
Climate & Stewardship Manager
NEXT Corporation
Tanguy Séné
Manager
COP26 Private Finance Hub
Willemijn Verdegaal
Co-Head, Climate & ESG Solutions
Ortec Finance
Themes:
- Adjusting expected returns, risks and diversification measures for carbon factors
- The cost saving benefits from green benchmarks
- The Pros and Cons of market vs custom indices
- Effect of benchmark inclusion on corporate behaviour
- Synchronising green index choices with the wider Net Zero Strategy
Group 3: Navigating the Green Asset Bubble
Facilitator:
David Hunter
Co-Founder & Chief Investment Officer
Renewity
Lead Discussants:
James Alexander
Chief Executive Officer
UKSIF
Megan Clay
Climate Finance Lawyer
ClientEarth
Danny Meehan
Head of Workplace Savings
Cushon
Themes:
- Which green assets, whether natural commodities or products, are especially overvalued?
- What headaches is this creating for investors?
- The conflict between maximising investment performance and meeting Net Zero targets.
- Effect on the trade-off between Greening the Fund vs Greening the World.
- How does the concept of fiduciary duty need to adapt? What has to give?
16.55 – 17.10
Return to Plenary & Feedback from Expert Discussions
17.10 – 17.50
Panel Discussion: A Focus on Natural Capital & Biodiversity
Moderator:
Julius Pursaill
Independent Member
Board Investment Committee
Royal London
George Graham
Fund Manager
South Yorkshire Pensions Authority
Vian Sharif
Founder
NatureAlpha
Rebecca Woods
ESG Research Analyst
Church Commissioners for England
Natural capital and ecosystems, biodiversity and climate change are all inextricably linked. For example, terrestrial and marine ecosystems currently absorb roughly half of manmade carbon emissions. Therefore, continuing ecosystem degradation and biodiversity loss is a major threat to meeting climate goals. The panel will debate how a focus on natural capital and biodiversity is going to become increasingly vital to delivering both net zero targets and investment performance for pension funds of all types.
Speakers will consider new products being developed which focus on the preservation of natural capital as a key strategic and investment goal, and the critical question of how access to these investment strategies is most effectively achieved.
17.50 – 18.10
Final Thoughts & Open Networking
Speakers
James Alexander
Chief Executive Officer
UKSIF
Bruno Bamberger
Solutions Strategist
AXA IM
Phil Beattie
Head of Sales
SparkChange
Ted Christie-Miller
Head of Carbon Removals
BeZero Carbon
Mike Clark
Founder Director
Ario Advisory
Megan Clay
Climate Finance Lawyer
ClientEarth
Marian Elliott
Global Head of Pensions
GFG Alliance
David Farrar
Climate & Stewardship Policy Manager
NEST Corporation
George Graham
Fund Director
South Yorkshire Pensions Authority
Caroline Hopper
Senior Writer
Quietroom
Jeff Houston
Head of Pensions
Local Government Association
David Hunter
Co-Founder & Chief Investment Officer
Renewity
Mel Jarman
Policy Maker
Department for Work & Pensions
Jennifer Law
Head of Stewardship
Newton Investment Management
Danny Meehan
Head of Workplace Savings
Cushon
Tanguy Séné
Manager
COP26 Private Finance Hub
Karen Shackleton
Director
Pensions for Purpose
Vian Sharif
Founder
NatureAlpha
Georgia Stewart
Co-Founder
Tumelo
Tom Tayler
Senior Manager
Aviva Investors
Rebecca Woods
ESG Research Analyst
Church Commissioners for England
Willemijn Verdegaal
Co-Lead, Climate & ESG Solutions
Ortec Finance
James Wilde
Chief Sustainability
Officer
Phoenix Group
Carol Young
Trustee
Natwest DC Plan